Did she lip synch? Was it the tape? Does it even matter? You be the judge with this wallpaper of Ashlee Simpson performing "live".

PLEASE CLICK LINK BELOW TO DOWNLOAD OUR ASHLEE SIMPSON LIVE WALLPAPER. A DOWNLOAD WINDOW WILL BE OPENED. (SORRY, CURRENTLY ONLY WORKS WITH INTERNET EXPLORER VERSION 5.0 OR NEWER)

Ashlee Simpson Live